Proggnosis Artist-Release Details

ProGGnosis Quick Search:     


a Studio release
Fates Warning

Release Year: 2004

Date Label Catalog # Comments
Metal Blade records
Added To Proggnosis Database on: 9/25/2004 12:00:00 AM
Entry Last Updated on: 9/13/2014 2:57:00 PM by: DBSilver
  1. Left Here
  2. Simple Human
  3. River Wide Ocean Deep
  4. Another Perfect Day
  5. Heal Me
  6. Sequence # 7
  7. Crawl
  8. A Handful Of Doubt
  9. Stranger (With A Familiar Face)
  10. Wish

Jim Matheos
lead & rhythm guitars

Ray Alder

Mark Zonder

Joey Vera

Reviewed by MJBrady on 09 Oct 2004

This band qualifies as one of the grandfathers of the genre called progressive metal, while many of the bands recordings are not progressive by nature, they did in fact have an era for which they did push the envelope for the integration of progressive elements with their notable metal side. Of late, Fates Warning seemingly had become a pale imitation of it's former self, particularly from a progressive stance, many of the bands most dedicated fans couldn't see the digression that occured with some of their more recent releases, because of their dedication, thinking the great FW could do no wrong, yet as often is the case, bands that are pioneers for a genre's creation are alway going to be held to the standard of their most notorious and innovative works. In the case of FW, they seemed to be getting even less progressive of late, hiding the talents of the bands musicianship, and focusing on straight ahead metal music, and for the folks that recall the bands APSOG, Parallels, and that era, they seemed to be another band going the way of non prog, much like their peers :Rush, Queensryche, etc.

Now here we have in 2004, FWX - the bands 10th release, and as progressive music goes, it seems the band has become content with the idea of being singer songwriters rather that performers from an instrumental standpoint, granted, they have always had good compositional skills, yet in the past, they were paring the two to create their own distinct style of music, which is why they were always used as a point of reference for the genre of Progmetal, along with the likes of Rush, DreamTheater, Queensryche, yet now, from what I am hearing, FW is strictly a Power Metal/Melodic Metal band, with but a few hints of progressive nuances added in between, in other words, for some, this is a great cd, for others, it's more of the same thing they heard on Disconnected, so however you felt about that one, this is taking off where that one ended, and no drastic changes to the format.

This is a nice sounding cd, especially if your favorite FW moments are the older and more metallized versions of the band, and it wouldn't be fair to simply dismiss the cd as being terrible or unimpressive, but as a progressive site, I am writing from a progressive perspective, and knowing what this band has done in the past with that in mind, I feel that they have parted ways with their prog roots, and are content to move in this more predictable and accessable direction, perhaps winning some new fans, while letting some older fans go, as often is the case, it's a gamble, time will tell where the band goes from here.