Proggnosis Artist-Release Details

ProGGnosis Quick Search:     

2 selections as Proggnosis Best of 2009 Release

The Underfall Yard

a Studio release
Big Big Train

Release Year: 2009

Date Label Catalog # Comments
2009 English Electric Recordings EERCD005
2010 MALS MALS 355
English Electric Recordings (EERCD005)
Added To Proggnosis Database on: 11/15/2009 12:00:00 AM
Entry Last Updated on: 5/9/2018 2:53:00 PM by: DBSilver
  1. Evening Star (4:53)
  2. Master James of St. George (6:19)
  3. Victorian Brickwork (12:33)
  4. Last Train (6:28)
  5. Winchester Diver (7:31)
  6. The Underfall Yard (22:59)

Greg Spawton
Guitars, keyboards, bass

David Longdon
Vocals, flute, glockenspiel

Andy Poole
Bass, keyboards


Nick D'Virgilio: Drums
Dave Gregory: Guitar solos, guitars, electric sitar
Jem Godfrey: Synthesizer solos
Dave Desmond: Trombone
Francis Dunnery: Guitar
Rich Evans: Cornet
Jon Foyle: Cello
Nick Stones: French horn
Jon Truscott: Tuba

Reviewed by Marc on 13 Dec 2009

I've been a Big Big Train fan ever since I got my hands on Bard (2002), an album that featured great melancholic symphonic prog in the tradition of 70's Genesis. After that the band put out two studio albums : Gathering Speed (2004) and The Difference Machine (2007), two excellent records that had a slight flaw, in my humble opinion, a lead singer (Phil Collins sound alike Sean Filkins) that pushed his voice to the limit a bit too often. Still Gathering Speed and The Difference Machine are albums that should be added to any symphonic prog fans' music collection. Recently, Big Big Train have been working on their back catalogue and making old stuff available again, a great pleasure for their many devoted fans. Now, nearing the end of 2009, a new cd is available... The Underfall Yard .

Until now my favorite Big Big Train album was Bard, but this is no longer the case. The Underfall Yard is a Gem among the Gems. All that I like about Big Big Train's music is in there. The writing and composing are at their best, the performances are just great (with a palette of talented guest musicians, Nick D'Virgilio not being the least) and the mood is mellower than on recent albums. Lead singer David Longdon is a great addition to the band. His voice is pretty close to Sean Filkins's, but he sings in a much more controled manner than his predecessor. Big Big Train has changed lead singer quite often, but I certainly hope that Longdon is a permanent addition to the band. In fact, if Big Big Train found the time to put Longdon's voice on previous recordings, I would certainly buy them even though I own the originals.

Time will tell if The Underfall Yard remains in my unofficial top 10 albums of all time list. For now, I can't help myself thinking of the best songs on A Trick of the Tail ("Entangled","Mad Man Moon"...) when I listen to this CD. Certainly my best album of 2009, and there has been many good ones (Porcupine Tree, Steve Hackett, IQ...). My highest recommendation indeed.